THE Commission on Audit (COA) flagged the Land Bank of the Philippines for granting a private contractor a P100-million credit line based on claims of its ability to deliver results.
Based on the agency’s 2025 annual audit report, LandBank president and chief executive officer Lynette Ortiz allegedly approved the [unnamed] contractor’s request to more than triple its credit line to P100 million based on sheer claims of bagging 22 government infrastructure projects.
In its audit report, COA said that the LandBank, the country’s second largest lender, initially doesn’t have validated copies of the contracts, which according to the state auditor, forms part of the list of requirements before approval.
A wholly-owned state bank by assets, LandBank raised the borrowing limit from P30 million on January 3, 2025 to P100 million on the basis of 14 ongoing Department of Public Works and Highways (DPWH) contracts and eight National Irrigation Administration (NIA) projects, based on the state bank’s 2025 annual audit report obtained by Bilyonaryo.
The borrower, identified only as “Borrower 1,” submitted a list detailing contract amounts, start dates, completion rates, target completion dates and outstanding receivables, but no supporting contracts or award documents.
LandBank maintained that it had verified the DPWH projects through the agency’s website. However, screenshots subsequently submitted to COA could not establish whether those checks had been conducted before the bank approved the increase.
The P70-million additional credit was granted under LandBank’s BUILDERS Program, which provides working capital to government and private-sector construction companies.
LandBank defended to COA its verification process, arguing that contract awards published on official government websites were authoritative and reliable records of project legitimacy.
Management said the online checks were sufficient to justify the increased borrowing limit and that the program’s guidelines allowed flexibility in validating contracts.
The bank also furnished copies of the awarded contracts, which were submitted by the borrower only at or before loan disbursement.
COA acknowledged the explanation but maintained that validated contracts were necessary safeguards to ensure credit approvals were supported by adequate documentary evidence.
The auditors traced the problem to the LandBank’s own guidelines under Executive Order No. 15, series of 2023, which required both project lists and validated awarded contracts but failed to distinguish documents needed before approval from those required before disbursement.
Unlike other LandBank lending programs, BUILDERS did not clearly separate pre-approval, pre-release and post-release requirements, leaving room for inconsistent interpretations.
COA uncovered another documentation weakness involving completed projects financed under BUILDERS.
Of 192 loan promissory notes booked at the LandBank head office as of August 31, 2025, auditors identified 26 associated with completed projects and requested their Project Accomplishment Reports.
The state bank argued that these were general working-capital facilities rather than loans tied to specific projects, making accomplishment reports unnecessary.
Management said its lending units instead conducted site visits and validations to ensure loan proceeds were used as intended.
But supporting records for those inspections could not readily be produced during the audit.
COA also found that the program’s guidelines did not clearly prescribe monitoring procedures for working-capital and short-term loan facilities.
The audit did not link these 26 promissory notes to the contractor granted the ₱100-million credit line.
From BUILDERS to NEXTBUILD
Following the audit, the LandBank informed COA that it had transitioned from BUILDERS to the NEXTBUILD Lending Program to strengthen internal controls and risk management.
While the revised guidelines were still being finalized, management said it had already issued an interim advisory directing lending units to adopt the enhanced requirements immediately.
The bank also agreed to clarify documentation requirements at each stage of lending and strengthen compliance monitoring, as recommended by COA.
