THREE students of the University of Makati (UMak) were arrested on Friday, November 13, 2026 while participating in a protest against Pax Silica in Taguig City.

News reports say the students were among the protesters expressing opposition to the initiative when police authorities confronted them over an allegedly unauthorized assembly. Student organizations claimed that officers confiscated placards and forcibly apprehended protesters. Videos circulating online reportedly showed confrontations between the police and demonstrators.

The trio were brought to a Taguig police station, and they face possible charge of alarms and scandal under the Revised Penal Code (RPC) and violation of the Batas Pambansa Blg. 880, also known as Public Assembly Act of 1985.

Can students be arrested for merely participating in a protest without a permit? Does the law prohibit demonstrations in public places? And when can police officers lawfully disperse a peaceful assembly? More importantly, does the right to protest depend on the government’s permission?

The Constitution Protects Peaceful Assembly

Article III, Section 4 of the 1987 Constitution expressly guarantees freedom of speech, of expression, and of the press, as well as the right of the people peaceably to assemble and petition the government for redress of grievances. These liberties are closely interconnected. Freedom of expression allows individuals to communicate their views and sentiments, while peaceful assembly enables them to express those views collectively. The Supreme Court, in Bayan v. Ermita, says these rights “enjoy primacy in the realm of constitutional protection. For these rights constitute the very basis of a functional democratic polity, without which all the other rights would be meaningless and unprotected.”

Thus, students may organize a demonstration against a government policy. Workers may rally for better wages. Residents may protest a proposed demolition, while environmental advocates may gather to oppose a project they believe threatens their community.

These activities are actual manifestations of democratic participation and meaningful exercise of their freedoms.

Significantly, the Constitution does not only safeguard opinions favorable to the government but also those that dissent, question, challenge, or criticize its policies. After all, the right to protest is meaningless if citizens can exercise it only when public authorities agree with they say.

What Does the Public Assembly Act Say?

B.P. Blg. 880 or the Public Assembly Act of 1985 governs the exercise of peaceful assembly in public places. As a matter of fact, Section 2 recognizes the constitutional right to peaceful assembly and petition as an essential component to the strength and stability of the State. It adds “the State shall ensure the free exercise of such right without prejudice to the rights of others to life, liberty and equal protection of the law.”

Meanwhile, Section 3(a) defines a public assembly to include rallies, demonstrations, marches, and other forms of collective action in public places intended to express opinions, advocate lawful causes, or protest political, economic, and social conditions.

Interestingly, the law does not prohibit public demonstrations. Instead, it regulates certain aspects of their conduct, particularly the time, place, and manner of assembly. This is what we call “content-neutral” regulation.

Meanwhile, under Section 4, a written permit is generally required to organize and hold a public assembly in a public place. Section 3(b) states that “public place” includes any highway, boulevard, avenue, road, street, bridge or other thoroughfare, park, plaza, square, and/or any open space of public ownership where the people are allowed access.

You need to remember, my dear Legal Classroom readers, this requirement is not absolute.

Where to Protest Without Permit?

Section 4 of B.P. 880 identifies important exceptions.

First, no permit is required in a duly established freedom park. These are places designated for the exercise of free speech and peaceful assembly. Freedom parks must be duly designated by an ordinance or established by a law. Examples include Liwasang Bonifacio and Plaza Miranda.

Second, no permit is required on private property, provided that the owner or person legally entitled to possess the property consents.

Third, no permit is required within the campus of a government-owned and operated educational institution, although the assembly remains subject to the institution’s rules and regulations.

Thus, students of a public university may generally organize a peaceful protest within their campus without obtaining a permit under B.P. 880, subject to applicable university regulations. However, the situation changes when the demonstration takes place outside the campus.

For instance, if students leave university premises and hold a rally on a public road, sidewalk, or plaza, the general permit requirement may apply unless the location falls within another recognized exception.

In addition, political meetings and rallies during election campaign periods, as provided by law, are also outside the coverage of B.P. 880.

Does the government have unlimited discretion to deny a permit?

Certainly not.

Under Section 5, organizers must generally submit their application to the city or municipal mayor at least five working days before the scheduled assembly.

Section 6 requires the mayor to grant the permit unless there is clear and convincing evidence that the assembly will create a clear and present danger to public order, safety, convenience, morals, or health.

Moreover, the mayor must act on the application within two working days. Otherwise, the permit is deemed granted. This only means that a mayor cannot simply deny a permit because the demonstration criticizes the President, opposes a government program, or expresses an unpopular political opinion. The government must establish a legally sufficient justification.

In Reyes v. Bagatsing (1983), the Supreme Court upheld the importance of peaceful assembly when authorities attempted to prevent an anti-American military bases rally near the United States Embassy. The Court emphasized that speculative fears of disorder are insufficient to suppress constitutionally protected expression.

Similarly, in Bayan v. Ermita (2006), the High Court upheld the constitutionality of B.P. 880 as a content-neutral regulation of the time, place, and manner of public assemblies. The Court also rejected the government’s policy of calibrated preemptive response insofar as it departed from the law’s requirement of maximum tolerance.

Remember: a permit regulates the use of public space; it is not a license to hold an opinion.

Can police disperse protesters without a permit?

Section 12 of B.P. 880 allows the peaceful dispersal of an assembly held without a permit when one is legally required. But dispersal and arrest are not necessarily the same.

Section 13(a) expressly provides that no person may be punished or held criminally liable merely for participating in or attending an otherwise peaceful assembly. This is vital in understanding the arrest of the three UMak students.

Even assuming arguendo that the demonstration required a permit and that none had been secured, it does not automatically follow that every participant could lawfully be arrested.

The law distinguishes between organizers who conduct a permit-required assembly without securing the necessary permit and ordinary participants who merely attend an otherwise peaceful demonstration.

Organizers may incur liability under B.P. 880 when its statutory elements are established. Ordinary peaceful participants, however, enjoy the express protection of Section 13(a).

Of course, participants are not exempt from liability for separate unlawful acts, such as violence or destruction of property. But mere participation in a peaceful protest should not be confused with criminal conduct.

What about maximum tolerance?

B.P. 880 also imposes obligations on law enforcement authorities.

Section 3(c) defines maximum tolerance as the highest degree of restraint that police and other peacekeeping authorities must observe during public assemblies and their dispersal.

Sections 9 to 12 establish added safeguards, including noninterference with lawful assemblies, restrictions on the use of anti-riot equipment, and procedures for dispersal.

In Bayan v. Ermita, the SC stressed that maximum tolerance protects demonstrators regardless of the political message they express. This principle must remind the police officers who confront protesters who are unarmed and peaceful.

A missing permit does not automatically justify punching, choking, or otherwise using excessive force against protesters. Any police use of force must have a lawful basis and satisfy applicable standards of necessity and proportionality.

If the allegations concerning the treatment of the UMak students are established, the conduct of the officers involved must be examined under these legal standards. They may be charged with appropriate criminal, civil, and administrative cases.

Can peaceful protesters be charged with alarms and scandal?

Reports concerning the UMak students indicate that they faced possible charges of alarms and scandal under Article 155 of the Revised Penal Code, as amended. This provision punishes certain acts that disturb public peace, including participation in disorderly meetings prejudicial to public tranquility and causing disturbances or scandals in public places.

However, a peaceful protest is not automatically a public scandal simply because it attracts attention, inconveniences authorities, or expresses an unpopular opinion. For example, students silently holding placards criticizing a government initiative are exercising expressive rights. Their activity does not become criminal merely because police officers disagree with the message.
Peaceful assembly is a democratic right

The Supreme Court has long recognized that public demonstrations are indispensable to democratic life. In Primicias v. Fugoso (1948), the Court emphasized that freedom of speech and peaceful assembly enjoy constitutional protection even when their exercise affects the ordinary use of streets and public places.

It is worth noting that public inconvenience and public danger are not necessarily the same. The State may regulate the time, place, and manner of demonstrations to protect public safety and the rights of others. However, it cannot use regulation as a convenient means of suppressing dissent.

The right to protest is not reserved for those who agree with the government. It belongs equally to students, workers, professionals, and ordinary citizens who wish to express their grievances.

The Constitution protects the right to speak. It also protects the right to stand together and be heard.

And while the State may regulate where and how public assemblies are conducted, it must never forget that the permit requirement is intended to regulate public space, not to silence the public’s voice. Class dismissed!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *