WHAT was once described and heralded as the “Duterte Magic” is a thing of the past. Rodrigo Duterte, the ex-president, who is now in jail for his bloody but ill-fated war on drugs, does not possess the political clout to entice and sway voters to elect his favored candidates in elections. He is passe, past tense, or a has-been, in plain words.
In brief, he does not have the power to influence the course of political developments in the country. As he faces a prolonged detention at the ICC prison facility in Netherlands, Duterte will be busy defending himself in the court trial that will start on Nov. 30. Duterte faces crimes against humanity charges, which Sonny Trillanes, Gary Alejano, and some left-wing activists have lodged against him before the ICC.
The results of the May 12, 2025 midterm elections summarized why the purported Duterte Magic is a foregone issue. Although his March 11, 2025 capture, arrest, and his trip and imprisonment was among the issues in the political campaign of the midterm elections, the results showed that Duterte was not an issue in any way.
The midterm elections were sort of a referendum on the Marcos-Duterte feud and a proxy war for Sara’s 2028 presidential bid, but the election results showed otherwise. Former Surigao del Norte Rep. Robert Ace Barbers said many Duterte candidates were routed and soundly beaten. They did not give a decent fight to show that it was sunset for the Dutertes.
Barbers said: “In Mindanao, 36 out of 44 lawmakers, who signed the fourth impeachment complaint were reelected. That’s 81.81% win rate. If impeachment was a liability, we would’ve been wiped out. But we were overwhelmingly returned.” Barbers was not the only one lawmaker who sounded pessimistic about the Dutertes and the impeachment issue.
For his part, Rep. Jude Acidre of the Tingog Party List said: “Just to set the record straight, these results dismantle the narrative that impeachment was a political liability. What we’re seeing is the public that values courage over complicity.” Mindanao had 60 congressional districts of which 44 lawmakers were reelectionists. The winning average of 81% was a feat.
Of the 115 reelectionist lawmakers, who signed the fourth impeachment complaint, 100 were reelected for a 87% win rate nationwide. Only 15 signatories lost and they were not reelected for various reasons, which did not point to their support of the fourth impeachment complaint against Sara, according to Acidre.
Rep. Joel Chua of the third district of Manila, who chaired the House Committee on Good Government and Public Accountability that probed the P612.5 million confidential fund, won over then Manila Councilor Apple Nieto, a candidate of Sara Duterte. To shame him, Sara herself went to the Manila District of Quiapo, Chua’s bailiwick, to raise Nieto’s hands and campaign against Chua, whom she regarded as a political enemy. But the opposite happened. Her efforts proved disastrous as Nieto lost dismally.
Rep. Rolando Valeriano of Manila’s second district,, who delivered the privilege speech that initiated the probe on the dubious use of the confidential fund, won overwhelmingly against his opponents in his home district of Tondo. Rep. Sandro Marcos, who was first to sign the Articles of Impeachment, won in Ilocos Norte. The same fate befell then Speaker Martin Romualdez, who signed last, as he won in his home district in Leyte.
Meanwhile, Davao del Sur Rep. John Tracy Cagas also won despite the fact that he was the only one of the 12 representatives in the Davao region, who signed the fourth impeachment rap. Then Rep. Majority Leader Manuel Jose Dalipe of Zamboanga City lost to Duterte-endorsed Khymer Olaso in their fight for mayor of that city.
Rep. Percival Cendaña of the Akbayan Party List surprised the electorate after his party list group topped the race after garnering 2.7 million votes. Overall, the party list groups that endorsed the impeachment complaint largely won. Barbers said: “They did not vote on candidates, who defended or attacked Duterte. They voted for local leaders who delivered.”
The outcome of the Senate race was pivotal. Half of the 24 seats in the Senate were contested. Two candidates – Paolo Benigno Aquino and Francis Pangilinan won along with the likes of Tito Sotto, Ping Lacson, Lito Lapid, and Erwin Tulfo, who were not aligned with the Dutertes. Their political victory balanced the other candidates, who were identified with the Duterte camp. They include Bong Go, Bato dela Rosa, Rodante Marcoleta, Camille Villar, and Imee Marcos.
In short, the House signatories survived in their reelection bids. It showed that their support for the impeachment was not a liability in their district races. It was Alyansa’s senatorial slate that suffered but it was not because of the impeachment issue. It was Toby Tiangco, Alyansa’s campaign manager, who was the problem. He did not do his job adequately as the campaign manager. In brief, he failed and his failure was dismal.
There were issues of betrayal and disloyalty in the midterm elections. Tiangco, a mediocre lawmaker who represents Navotas City in the House of Representatives, failed dismally to put a number of proadministration candidates in the winning column. After the stinging loss, the anime looking Tiangco blamed the impeachment process for the political losses.
According to the weird looking Tiangco, the House’s move to send the Articles of Impeachment to the Senate on Feb. 5 hurt the chances of the Alyansa’s Senate slate in Mindanao, which was considered a Duterte country because of the inordinate numbers of voters, who speak the Cebuano dialect. Barbers and Acidre had a different narrative calling Tiango’s statement as “misleading and detached from real sentiment.”
The Senate loss was due to poor campaign management. It only had 21 sorties and there was no local government unit (LGU) machinery for the Senate slate. Moreover, there was failure to handle Imee Marcos and Camille Villar’s sudden defection to Sara’s camp and the sympathy wave in Mindanao after the March 11 arrest of Rodrigo Duterte. There was no leadership in Toby Tiangco’s party. All he did was negligence.
Where is Rodrigo Duterte’s political magic? It is gone with the wind.
