BUDGET watchdog, Zy-za Nadine Suzara criticized the P7.2 trillion national budget for 2027 as laden with pork barrel and questionable insertions, lacked transparency, reforms and accountability and excluded civil society in the whole budgeting process.

In an interview with Bilyonaryo News Channel, Suzara, a public finance specialist and representing the People’s Budget Coalition, asserted that lawmakers lied when they claimed there is no pork barrel in the budget process. 

She said funds were hidden inside ‘unprogrammed appropriations’ (which Supreme Court justices earlier labelled as another term for the outlawed pork barrel) rather than programmed funds meant for national development.

Funds channeled into soft projects and assistance programs like AKAP, MAIP and AICS which were distributed through individual lawmakers. (AKAP stands for Ayuda para sa Kapos ang Kita Program, MAIP is Medical and Financial Assistance Program, AICS is Assistance to Individuals in Crisis Situations and TUPAD is Tulong Panghanapbuhay sa ating Disadvantaged/Displaced workers under DOLE).

Substantial project allocations were given to high-ranking House leaders and key committee chairs, Suzana claimed.

She stated that civil society organizations were completely locked out of the budget-drafting process, contradicting claims of transparency by the House.

She urged President Marcos Jr to veto specific portions of the 2027 spending measure. 

Suzara is the Executive Director of the Institute for Leadership, Empowerment and Democracy (iLEAD),  a non-stock, non-profit think tank and resource center focused on fiscal policy research, advocacy, and good governance. She is also affiliated with: People’s Budget Coalition and Access Bangsamoro (where she serves as research fellow).

In April 2022 (at the latter part of President Rodrigo Duterte), she participated in the forum organized by UPLB College of Public Affairs and Development and the College of Economics and Management as part of the campus’ Halalan 2022 forum on the national and local elections, where she presented the topic “The Politics of the 2022 National Budget.” 

Having served at the Departments of Budget and Management and Trade and Industry, her expertise on the national budget is regularly tapped by the House of Representatives and the Senate. 

Back then, she observed the government’s “continued insistence on the ‘brute force’ approach to infrastructure,” by allocating the highest budget for the Department of Public Works and Highways (DPWH), specifically for its Build Build Build Program, amounting to P786.73 billion, despite not having a technical study showing the multiplier effects of the past investments on infrastructure. 

She raised her concern on the “bloated unprogrammed appropriations (UA),” which have no sure source of financing. Grouped under the UA are crucial health, education, and economic recovery programs for the pandemic. She pointed out that the health sector continues to lack funding and support, despite health experts foreseeing an increase in COVID-19 cases after the elections. 

The military and law enforcement had a demanding share of the national budget, with the government needing P800 billion annually for 20 years to fund the  pensions for military and uniformed personnel totaling P9.6 trillion, thereby causing the ballooning of debt and posing a serious financial burden to the government, if not overhauled. 

Suzara discussed possible constitutional issues in the 2022 GAA, stating that “the Congress may not increase the appropriations recommended by the President for the operation of the Government as specified in the budget.” 

Still, the 2022 National Expenditure Plan from the executive branch saw an increase in the 2022 GAA by P100 billion for pork projects under the DPWH.

Suzara then concluded that the fiscal problems that will be left behind by the Duterte Administration will go beyond the ballooning debts and deficits, and recommended that the next administration make serious fiscal policy and public financial management reforms.