“WALANG kwenta.”
“Nakatunganga lang.”
These were the two derogatory remarks reportedly made about Joshua “Josh” Aquino, the eldest son of TV host-actress Kris Aquino, during an episode of the Machong Chismisan podcast. The hosts were talking about Josh and his younger brother, Bimby, when one of them made disparaging comments about Josh, who, as a matter of public knowledge, belongs to the autism spectrum.
The said utterances sparked widespread criticism, specifically from disability advocates and netizens who found these comments pejorative, offensive, and discriminatory.
The whole nation, including government agencies, civic and professional organizations, among others, has defended Josh, Bimby, and Kris. As a result of the backlash, the podcasters issued an apology, while The Pod Network afterwards terminated its contract with the show.
PWDs’ Legal Shield
It is an established legal fact that someone making fun of persons with a disability, subjecting them to public ridicule, and vilifying them is not only a violation of the law but an affront to public policy and good customs.
Republic Act No. 7277, otherwise known as the Magna Carta for Disabled Persons (now Persons with Disabilities), as amended by Republic Act No. 9442, protects PWDs against discrimination, public ridicule, and vilification.
Under Section 39, public ridicule refers to making fun of, contemptuously imitating, or mocking a person because of his or her disability, whether through words, writing, or actions. Section 40 prohibits such conduct when it could intimidate or result in the loss of self-esteem of a PWD.
The law also prohibits vilification. Under Sections 41 and 42, this includes making slanderous or abusive statements against a PWD or engaging in public activities that incite hatred, serious contempt, or severe ridicule, under the circumstances specified by law.
For example, deliberately imitating the speech of a person with a developmental disability to entertain an audience, making degrading remarks about someone’s intellectual limitations, or publicly humiliating someone because of a disability may constitute the aforementioned prohibited acts.
In the age of podcasts, livestreams, and social media, these provisions become particularly relevant where derogatory remarks may reach thousands of people within seconds.
Thus, describing a person with a disability as “walang kwenta” or ridiculing his behavior may raise serious legal questions, especially when the statements are directed at the person because of his disability.
The Magna Carta also provides penalties for violations. Under Section 46, a first offense may be punished by a fine ranging from Php50,000 to Php100,000, imprisonment of six months to two years, or both. Subsequent violations carry heavier penalties.
Take note, my dear Legal Classroom readers, whether particular remarks constitute public ridicule or vilification punishable under the law must be determined from the circumstances and evidence through the appropriate legal proceedings.
Civil Code and Dignity
Interestingly, the protection of human dignity is not confined to the Magna Carta.
The Civil Code of the Philippines contains several provisions that may provide remedies against degrading or injurious conduct.
Article 19 embodies the principle of abuse of rights, requiring every person to act with justice, give everyone his due, and observe honesty and good faith in exercising rights and fulfilling obligations.
This article reminds us that the possession of a legal right does not necessarily justify every means of exercising it.
For instance, a podcaster may invoke freedom of expression as a constitutional right. But when that freedom is deliberately exercised in a way that is contrary to the rights and dignity of another individual, the conduct may give rise to legal consequences.
In addition, Article 20 provides that a person who causes damage to another through an act contrary to law, whether willfully or negligently, shall indemnify the injured person.
Meanwhile, Article 21 imposes civil liability upon anyone who willfully causes injury to another in a manner contrary to morals, good customs, or public policy. Article 26 likewise requires every person to respect the dignity, personality, privacy, and peace of mind of others. It recognizes civil remedies for certain acts that offend these protected interests.
These provisions entail a significant principle: the exercise of one’s rights must be accompanied by respect for the rights and dignity of others.
Thus, even when particular conduct does not result in a criminal conviction, it may still give rise to civil liability if the elements of an applicable Civil Code provision are established.
Constitutional Value
The 1987 Constitution likewise recognizes the dignity of every person.
Article 2, Section 11 declares that the State values the dignity of every human person and guarantees full respect for human rights.
Article 13, Section 13 specifically orders the State to establish a special agency for persons with disabilities to promote their rehabilitation, self-development, self-reliance, and integration into mainstream society.
These constitutional provisions provide the foundation for laws protecting PWDs against discrimination and degrading treatment.
Not Diminishing Worth
What makes the controversy particularly troubling is the suggestion that a person with a developmental disability is somehow less valuable because of his perceived limitations.
Calling someone “walang kwenta” reinforces the harmful notion that human worth depends on intelligence, productivity, physical ability, or conformity to society’s expectations.
But human dignity is not measured by academic achievement, employment, popularity, or financial success. Neither does a person lose dignity because of a disability.
The controversy should therefore remind content creators, comedians, influencers, and ordinary social media users that freedom of expression carries responsibilities.
There are countless ways to make people laugh without turning another person’s disability into a spectacle.
A person’s disability does not diminish his worth. Neither does another person’s popularity give him the right to diminish it.
Because under Philippine law, dignity belongs to everyone. With or without disability.
Class dismissed!
