FOR the past few days, an almost two-decade-old controversy involving actor Patrick Garcia and actress Jennylyn Mercado has reappeared on social media.
At the center of the renewed online buzz is their son, Alex Jazz.
In a recent interview with TV host and manager Ogie Diaz, Garcia revisited his past relationship with Mercado and addressed, among others, the issue of financial support for their son. Garcia’s statements did not sit well with netizens, with people taking sides on questions of fatherhood, access to a child, and financial responsibility.
I will leave the personal controversy to the parties themselves.
However, this issue raises a legal question that affects thousands of Filipino families: What exactly is a father legally mandated to provide his child? Or, in other words: Ano ba talaga ang ibig sabihin ng sustento?
Under Philippine law, support is not merely a moral or ethical duty of the person obliged to give one. More than anything else, it is a legal obligation.
More Than Giving Money
Article 194 of the Family Code enumerates what “support” actually includes. It covers everything indispensable for sustenance, dwelling, clothing, medical attendance, education, and transportation, taking into consideration the financial capacity of the family.
Thus, when we speak of sustento, we are not talking merely about money for food. Tuition may be part of support. So are medicines and medical expenses. Clothing, housing, transportation to and from school, and other necessities may likewise fall within and under it.
As a matter of fact, education may even be covered beyond the age of majority, or legal age, when it involves schooling or training for a profession, trade, or vocation. So, the popular statement, “Eighteen ka na, wala na akong obligasyon sa iyo,” is not necessarily legally correct.
Both Parents Have Obligation
Another misconception is that child support is exclusively the father’s responsibility. It is not.
Article 195 of the Family Code imposes the obligation of support upon parents and their children, whether the children are marital or non-marital (legitimate or illegitimate). Thus, both mother and father have accountabilities toward their kid.
Neither can simply say, “Sa nanay naman nakatira,” or “Sa tatay naman nakatira,” and assume that this automatically extinguishes the obligation.
More importantly, the law does not distinguish between a marital and non-marital child when it comes to the basic right to receive support from his or her parents. Whatever happened between the mother and father is a matter between adults. The child should not be made to suffer for it.
How Much Should Dad Give?
This is probably one of the most usual questions asked by separated parents: “Attorney, magkano ba dapat ang sustento?”
The answer: There is no single amount applicable to everyone. There is no rule saying that every father must automatically give Php5,000, Php10,000, or Php20,000 every month.
Article 201 of the Family Code provides the fundamental formula: the amount of support must be proportionate to the resources or means of the person giving support and the necessities of the person receiving it. Thus, “the amount of support…shall be in proportion to the resources or means of the giver and to the necessities of the recipient.”
In simple terms, the Family Code looks at two things: How much does the child reasonably need, and how much can the parent reasonably afford?
A father earning minimum wage obviously cannot be expected to provide the same amount as a father earning hundreds of thousands of pesos every month. Also, a financially capable parent cannot deliberately give a token amount that is clearly insufficient for the child’s reasonable needs. The amount is not permanently fixed.
Under Article 202, support may be increased or reduced when the needs of the child or the financial capacity of the parent changes.
“Hindi ko naman nakikita ang anak ko.”
This brings us to two important concerns: What if the father is prevented from seeing the child? Can he stop giving support?
As a general proposition, support and visitation are separate and distinct legal issues. The obligation to support arises from the parent-child relationship. A dispute between the parents over custody or visitation does not, by itself, erase the child’s need for food, education, medicine, clothing, and shelter.
A parent who believes that his or her rights to custody or visitation are being unjustly denied has legal remedies available under the different laws.
Remember, parents, the child should not become the bargaining chip.
“Hindi mo ipapakita sa akin ang anak ko, kaya hindi ako magsusustento” is a dangerous way of looking at parental obligations because support belongs ultimately to the child.
When can support be demanded?
Article 203 provides another rule that parents should take into consideration.
The obligation to give support becomes demandable from the time the person entitled to it needs it for maintenance. However, as a rule, payment is recoverable only from the date of judicial or extrajudicial demand.
That is reason a written demand for support may actually be legally substantial. A demand does not necessarily begin with a lawsuit. An extrajudicial demand may establish that the parent obligated to provide support was already being asked to fulfill that obligation.
If the matter reaches court, support pendente lite, or temporary support while the case is pending, may also be sought under the applicable rules.
What if a parent simply refuses?
The Family Code anticipated this situation.
Article 207 provides that when a person legally obliged to support another unjustly refuses or fails to give support when urgently needed, another person may provide that support and later seek reimbursement from the person who should have provided it.
The law specifically mentions the situation where a father or mother unjustly refuses or fails to support a minor child. In proper cases, therefore, a parent may be brought to court and ordered to provide support.
Failure to comply with a lawful court order may bring additional legal problems. There may also be situations where deliberate deprivation of financial support becomes relevant under Republic Act No. 9262, or the Anti-Violence Against Women and Their Children Act. But not every failure or inability to give support automatically constitutes a crime. Criminal liability is dependent on the specific facts, the elements required by law, and the evidence presented.
Take note, parents.
There is a huge distinction between “cannot provide” and “will not provide.” The law takes into account the financial capacity of the individual obligated to provide support. A father who lost his livelihood is in a different position from one who has enough means but purposefully declines to give support for his child.
Support is child’s basic right
Maybe, this is the point that often gets lost when former couples fight over money.
Support is not a mere money given by one former partner to another. Principally, it is intended for the child.
The relationship between the father and the mother may end. Their affection toward each other may disappear. Communication may become difficult. They may enter into new relationships. Both may eventually establish new families.
But remember: parenthood remains—factually and legally.
Whatever disagreements parents may have with each other should not deprive a child of what the law recognizes as essential for his or her growth, education, health, and dignity.
The Family Code makes that obligation clear. A relationship may end. But being a parent does not. And neither does the obligation that comes with it.
Class dismissed!
