IN THE Philippines, political dynasties can never be dismantled as long as there are poor, unwashed and unlearned people willing to cling to them for patronage/aid and for so long as dynasties can count on the poor’s unwavering votes to stay in power.
Political dynasties and poverty are deeply connected through a cyclical relationship where poverty entrenches political clans, and certain types of dynasties further exacerbate economic underdevelopment.
Attempts by both chambers of Congress to come up with bills against political dynasties have at best been just for show, nothing serious and nothing intended to end this vicious societal malaise.
Through the years, in poverty-stricken areas, voters often rely heavily on immediate financial aid, jobs, or dole-outs from powerful families. Political clans use public resources to fund these patronage networks, making voters dependent on them for survival.
In remote areas where poverty is high and inequality limits the ability of ordinary, non-wealthy citizens who enter politics realize the enormous challenges like a deep war chest (substantial resources and wide networks) thereby giving established families with name recognition and amassed wealth an insurmountable advantage.
Research groups like the Ateneo School of Government have shown that poverty directly entrenches political dynasties by weakening independent institutional checks and civic participation.
The study distinguishes between fat and thin dynasties (with the former characterized by multiple family members holding multiple elected positions simultaneously within a provinces) that ironically lead to worse developmental outcomes and deeper poverty (with only the dynasty growing meteorically in power, influence and wealth) particularly in resource-rich regions outside Luzon.
Studies show the negative economic impact of dynasties varying by region with Luzon, a more competitive local business environment tempering some adverse effects of dynasties while areas outside Luzon have collusive business-government elites showing how dynasties actively exacerbate poverty.
The Catholic Educational Association of the Philippines, in its recent findings, stated that democracy suffers when political power becomes concentrated, weakening public accountability and diverting funds away from long-term infrastructure into short-term patronage.
Reducing the power of political clans requires expanding independent economic opportunities and livelihood programs so voters are less vulnerable to dole-outs.
Strengthening public transparency, enforcing anti-dynasty provisions (such as enabling legislation for the constitutional ban), and leveling the electoral playing field are vital to restoring institutional accountability, studies
Either poverty brings about political dynasties, or political dynasties fail to reduce, or even exacerbate, poverty, according to the findings of the study “Political dynasties and poverty: Evidence from the Philippines” authored by R. Mendoza Jr., E. Venida and D. Yap.
The empirical findings suggest that poverty entrenches political dynasties, while there is less evidence to prove that political dynasties exacerbate poverty.
Another report of the Catholic Education Association of the Philippines (CEAP) clearly states that “democracy suffers when political power becomes difficult for ordinary citizens to enter and difficult for institutions to challenge.”
Last August, the Supreme Court prodded Congress of its mandatory constitutional duty to enact an anti-political dynasty law and the prolonged inaction had exceeded a reasonable period.
It recommended the limit to political dynasties of up to fourth (and not second as espoused by both chambers of Congress) degree of relations (by blood or marriage) or until first cousins, great uncles, great aunts, grand nieces and grand nephews and great, great grandparents by blood and first cousins- in- law and spouses of great aunts and great uncles by marriage.
“A second-degree limit covers immediate family relationships. A fourth-degree limit reaches a wider network of blood and marital relationships and addresses the possibility of political families distributing positions among relatives beyond the immediate household,” the CEAP said.
Concentrating political power in the hands of a few families “weakens political competition and narrows access to public service. It can deepen patronage, clientelism, vote-buying and political dependency,” the group stressed.
Ecological protection belongs in the political dynasty debate, the CEAP said.
“The issue concerns who controls decisions over resources that affect everyone. It concerns who receives the benefits and who carries the costs. It concerns environmental justice, human dignity, participation and the protection of creation for present and future generations,” the CEAP said.
