
WITH the Philippine Congress dominated by the “chosen few,” not even a constitutional provision could put an end to the centuries-old culture of political dynasty.
Even the Supreme Court must have gotten tired with the foot-dragging of Congress to pass an honest-to-goodness anti dynasty law.
According to the Supreme Court, “39 years of waiting is long enough,” citing an exasperation that has been vented by the public for decades — families and clans monopolizing power positions from the highest government position down to the lowest barangay level.
The SC said: “39 years is beyond a reasonable period to carry out the constitutional command. Respondent, Congress of the Philippines is declared to have the mandatory constitutional duty to enact the law, the Congress of the Philippines must henceforth and with utmost urgency enact the appropriate anti-political dynasty law at the earliest opportunity.”
A political dynasty is the concentration of political power and public office within the same family or clan, explained the Inquirer.
The full court decision penned by Associate Justice Ramon Paul Hernando granted three consolidated petitions filed by 1Sambayan Coalition—led by retired Supreme Court Associate Justice Antonio Carpio and retired Ombudsman Conchita Carpio Morales, the Kapatiran Party, Witlfredo Trinidad et al., along with groups of legal scholars and civic leaders.
The petitions challenged Congress’s prolonged failure to pass a law defining and prohibiting political dynasties.
In its ruling, SC spokesperson Atty. Camille Ting, said, “The Supreme Court unanimously declared that Article Two, Section 26 of the Constitution requires Congress to enact a law prohibiting political dynasties. The Supreme Court held that Congress’s failure to do so for thirty-nine years constitutes grave abuse of discretion.”
Article 2, Section 26 of the Constitution provides that the “State shall guarantee equal access to opportunities for public service and prohibit political dynasties as may be defined by law.
Ting said the Supreme Court held that this provision is not merely an aspiration but a constitutional command.
“The use of the word ‘shall’ makes clear that the State has a mandatory duty both to guarantee equal access to public service and to prohibit political dynasties,” she said, adding that while the phrase ‘as may be defined by law’ “gives Congress the authority to define what constitutes a political dynasty and determine the scope of the prohibition,” not the choice of whether to prohibit them.
Ting took note of the SC’s observation that political dynasties “have remained widespread and have extended even into the party-list system. Despite changes in the composition of Congress over the years, no comprehensive anti-political dynasty law has been enacted, implying either a lack of interest, avoidance for convenience, or service of self-interest.”
Although the Constitution does not set a deadline, the SC said 39 years is already “beyond a reasonable period.”
