FORMER China Bank executive Alexander Escucha came up with a two- part column  series in Business World debunking the supposed “consumption culture” of Filipinos, which is why they save less. He did so because of the query of Senator Erwin Tulfo on why the peso keeps falling. I will present an abridged version of his column here.

Citing the Engel’s Law (1857), which says that poor households spend a much larger share of income on food and basic necessities, leaving little or nothing for savings as the real culprit.

Based on the 2025 FIES (or the Family Income and Expenditures Survey released on August 26, food and non-alcoholic beverages accounted for the largest share of total annual family expenditures in all regions except NCR where it was 25.7  percent (slightly behind housing at 27.3 percent). Lower-income households spend 55 to 60 percent of their income on food alone.

For lower-income households spending 55 to 60 percent on food, only 40 to 45 percent remains for housing, utilities, transport, healthcare, education, and savings. After allocating 25 to 30 percent to essential services and education, the buffer for savings drops to 5 to 10 percent,

When food and basic necessities consume up to 90 percent of a household’s income, there is no room for savings — not because the household is frivolous, but because Engel’s Law is inviolable without income growth.

With nearly half the population spending 55 percent plus of its income on food, leaving only 10 to 15 percent for housing, utilities, health, education, and savings, the national savings rate cannot rise meaningfully without income growth at the bottom. It’s mathematics, not character. It’s economics, not culture, Escucha explained.

By contrast an OFW family receiving P30,000 in monthly remittances (on P10,000 domestic income) has P40,000 total. The household can save, invest in education, build a house but not because OFWs are less mayabang but because they’ve escaped the Engel coefficient through higher income.

The BSP Survey of Overseas Filipinos (Q1 2024, n=324 households) documents show OFW households allocate remittances across multiple purposes. A single household typically uses remittances for multiple purposes simultaneously: 96.6 percent for food and household needs;  63.9 percent invest in education (human capital formation);  58.3 percent for  medical expenses (human health maintenance); 32.1 percent save remittances (financial capital accumulation); 18.8 percent spent on consumer durables: refrigerators, solar panels, electrical appliances (semi-durable capital goods); and 10.8 percent for purchase/construct homes (physical capital formation).

The pattern is clear: nearly all OFW households (96.6 percent) prioritize food security, most (63.9 percent) prioritize education, and a significant group (32.1 percent) actively save. The fact that education ranks second only to food — before even basic consumption — contradicts any narrative of frivolity or mayabang spending.

WRONG DIAGNOSIS

A family that spends 58 to 75 percent on food is not indulgent. It is income-constrained by the hierarchy of human needs. Asking such a family to save more is like asking someone to lift themselves by their bootstraps. Savings can only rise when the income grows enough that necessities fall below 50 percent of the budget.

This applies equally to remittance-receiving households that cannot save more when remittances are used to catch up on deferred consumption (education backlogs, medical care, housing repairs) or to buffer against income volatility.

The Philippines’ savings rate problem is fundamentally an income distribution problem. With at least a third of the population near poverty, and poverty defined as income level INSUFFICIENT to meet basic needs, savings cannot surge without reducing poverty.

Blaming Filipinos for being mayabang is only a very partial view, hence inaccurate. It diverts attention from the hard work of raising incomes, improving competitiveness, and creating better jobs. The Philippines’ savings rate will rise when Filipino incomes rise. Not before. And not through moral exhortation.