THE possibility of an acquittal looks bleak for Vice President Sara Duterte as the Senate impeachment court ruled to lower the number of votes required to convict the second highest elected official in the country.
Voting 13 against one, the Senate impeachment court ruled to interpret the constitutional provision based on the presence of the senator-judges taking part in the impeachment proceedings.
Hence, the voting threshold is reduced to 14 votes, which represents 2/3 of the 20 participating senator-judges.
Article XI, Section 3(6) of the 1987 Constitution, mandates that no person shall be convicted in an impeachment trial without the concurrence of two-thirds of all the Members of the Senate.
ABSENTEE SENATORS
Under the current situation, four senators have not been able to take part in the impeachment process for various reasons.
Senators Jinggoy Estrada and Rodante Marcoleta are under detention pending the resolution of the court over plunder charges.
Senator Loren Legarda, who is on an “extended medical leave” has gone to France for treatment of “serious lung disease.”
Meanwhile, Senator Ronald “Bato” Dela Rosa has is nowhere to be found amid an arrest warrant issued by the International Criminal Court (ICC), in connection with the crimes against humanity filed against the supposed perpetrators of the bloody war against drugs during the previous administration.
DISSENTING VOTE
Of the 14 senator-judges in attendance during the voting last Friday, only one stood against the bid to lower the voting threshold — Presiding Officer Francis Escudero.
Despite going against the decision, Escudero said he would enforce it as the court’s “new controlling ruling.”
“While the chair takes exception to this decision, the chair nonetheless accepts it as a judgment of this court and is bound to give it effect,” Escudero said.
“Accordingly, the chair accepts and declares the ruling adopted by the court as the new controlling ruling upon further proceedings and the chair shall apply this ruling faithfully,” he added.
MINORITY BOYCOTT
Interestingly, minority senators opted not to participate in the vote after previously maintaining that the impeachment court should not decide to alter the number of votes required to convict Duterte.
The boycotting senator-judges include Alan Peter Cayetano, Pia Cayetano, Imee Marcos, Bong Go, Camille Villar and Robinhood Padilla.
Conspicuously missing from the dissenting roster is Senator Mark Villar, who voted in favor of the motion. The other 12 votes came from members of the majority bloc.
The 13 who voted to adopt the new threshold were Senate President Sherwin Gatchalian, Senate President Pro Tempore Vicente Sotto III, Senate Majority Leader Juan Miguel Zubiri, Risa Hontiveros, Francis “Kiko” Pangilinan, JV Ejercito, Raffy Tulfo, Erwin Tulfo, Joel Villanueva, Bam Aquino, Panfilo Lacson, Lito Lapid and Mark Villar.
CONTROLLING RULING
Under the “new controlling ruling,” the phrase “all members of the Senate” in the Constitution’s impeachment provision will refer to members who, at the time of the vote, remain legally and factually capable of participating in the proceedings.
Excluded from the computation are senators who are in jail or suspended or otherwise legally restrained from exercising their functions. Barred from exercising power to vote insofar as issuing the verdict whether or not to convict Duterte are fugitives from justice, physically or medically incapacitated.
“Where the computation of two-thirds results in a fraction, the number of votes required for conviction shall be rounded up to the next higher whole number, even if the fraction is less than 0.5,” Escudero explained.
“Since a fraction of a vote is impossible as there is no fraction of a senator, 13.33—again by way of example only—must be rounded up to 14 votes, the next higher whole number to ensure that the votes for conviction constitute at least two-thirds of the relevant membership,” he added.
