ALTHOUGH Senator-Judge Alan Peter Cayetano vowed not to participate in the impeachment voting if the 16-threshold specified by the Constitution as ⅔ of all Senators is changed, former Senate President Franklin Drilon said there would be no ‘mistrial’ if the court changes the 16-vote ruling.

Drilon dismissed as wrong and baseless Cayetano’s claims that reversing the impeachment court’s earlier ruling requiring 16 votes for conviction in the middle of the trial of Vice President Sara Duterte would result in a mistrial.

Drilon said that the June 6 ruling of Presiding Officer Francis Escudero may still be appealed before the entire impeachment court, according to an interview with DzBB over the weekend.

“That is incorrect. There is no basis for the claim of a mistrial,” Drilon said.

Cayetano earlier warned that changing the ruling which set the conviction threshold at 16 votes or two-thirds of the Senate’s full 24-member membership, could lead to a mistrial.

Drilon said that Escudero deliberately did not structure his ruling as final in anticipation of potential legal challenges and to allow the Supreme Court to weigh in on the issue, considering the absence of several senator-judges.

“A mistrial? That’s incorrect. First of all, Senator Escudero’s ruling can be appealed to the impeachment court—to the 24 senators, or however many there are—who constitute that court. That’s why his ruling is not set in stone,” Drilon emphasized.

“In fact, he acknowledges that an appeal can be made to the Supreme Court en banc; therefore, the claim of a mistrial is baseless,” he added.