BETWEEN 2024 and 2025, the Department of Public Works and Highways awarded 11,391 projects worth P459.262 billion to undercapitalized or dubiously-funded contractors.
The Commission on Audit, in its 2025 report that was released last October 30, said that 27,094 infrastructure contracts out of the 47,469 were awarded by DPWH Central office and 16 regional offices from January 1, 2024 to August 31, 2025.
The state auditors flagged 11,391 contracts involving bidders who submitted incomplete Statements of Ongoing Government and Private Contracts resulting in inaccurate disclosures of contractual commitments and incorrect computation of their Net Financial Contracting Capacity (NFCC), Malaya Business Insight reported.
The NFCC is the financial metric used by the government to determine if a contractor is eligible to bid for a public works contract. It is computed based on the balance of a contractor’s assets against its liabilities, including commitments relative to ongoing projects.
The audit team revealed that the DPWH allowed contractors to bag government projects despite failure to submit complete, accurate, and valid NFCC computations that should have reflected their actual financial capacity at the time of bidding.
The auditors blamed the defective post qualification procedures undertaken by the DPWH Bids and Awards Committee (BAC) and Technical Working Group (TWG).
“Review of the 27,094 sampled infrastructure contracts disclosed that 11,391 contracts, with an aggregate contract cost of P459.262 billion, involved bidders whose submitted Statements of Ongoing Government and Private Contracts did not completely reflect their ongoing and awarded but not yet started contractual commitments,” the audit team said.
Based on the report, the five regions with the biggest number of contracts awarded to bidders with deficient disclosures were Region 1 (Ilocos Region) with 1,893; Region 10 (Northern Mindanao) with 1,328; Region 4A (Calabarzon) with 1,289; Region 2 (Cagayan Valley) with 1,213; and Region 3 (Central Luzon) with 1,134.
In terms of contract cost, however, the five regions with the biggest total contract costs awarded to bidders with doubtful NFCC were Region 4B (Mimaropa) with P65.708 billion; Region 10 (Northern Mindanao) with P63.559 billion; Region 1 (Ilocos Region) with P45.76 billion; Region 2 (Cagayan Valley) with P43.553 billion; and Region 4A (Calabarzon) with P41.655 billion.
Loopholes
The scheme took advantage of several loopholes like incomplete declaration of ongoing and awarded but not yet started contract; NFCC computations were not updated in subsequent bid; and non-disclosure of projects undertaken with other government agencies, local government units, government-owned or controlled corporations and private entities.
“(I)t was observed that bidders with undeclared ongoing and awarded but not yet started projects were still considered eligible, provided that they had a positive NFCC,” auditors said.
DPWH officials shifted the blame to BAC-TWG saying it relied heavily on the eligibility results generated by the DPWH Civil Works Application (CWA) which exclusively contained only DPWH-awarded contracts.
The officials also acknowledged the “absence of a systematic or independent mechanism for cross-checking contractors’ declared commitments against their actual ongoing government projects” even as they admitted that it is “a critical factor for assessing the accuracy and completeness of NFCC submissions.”
In addition, the DPWH also cited time constraints, which limits the period for post-qualification, as well as practical limitations caused by the volume of procurement transactions, availability of data, and manpower shortage to independently verify the bidders’ submissions.
To illustrate the effect of inaccurate NFCC computations, the report provided the breakdowns of projects cornered by two bidders identified only as Contractor B and C in 2024.
According to records, the first project won by Contractor B was awarded on January 30, 2024, worth P144,749,909.05. Deducted against its computed NFCC of P226.34 million, the remaining NFCC should have gone down to P81.59 million.
Still Contractor B continued to bid – and win – four additional multi-million contracts all in just six days.
It was awarded a second project worth P144,749,748.02 on the same day as the first.
Three days later (February 2, 2024), it won two more projects worth P144,749,005.78 and P96,499,221.60.
After three more days, or on February 5, 2024, it won the fifth project worth P144,749,278.58 bringing its total project cost at P675.5 million, way beyond its original NFCC.
The same pattern was observed in the case of Contractor C, which won a total of seven contracts with an aggregate value of P1.004 billion in just three days against an NFCC computation of just P189.75 million.
The first five contracts were all awarded on January 30, 2024, worth P140.16 million, P144.75 million, P140.16 million, P144.75 million, and P144.75 million.
The fourth and fifth contracts were awarded on the same day, February 2, 2024, both worth P144.75 million.
“Considering the cumulative value of the succeeding contracts awarded to the same contractors, the remaining NFCC was no longer sufficient to satisfy the required financial eligibility for the subsequent awards,” the audit team pointed out. But the DPWH, however, saw things differently.
“Management commented that the NFCC was also validated and checked for accuracy during the post-qualification stage to ensure compliance with the required contracting capacity. Furthermore, these projects had not yet been awarded, so they were not considered in the computation of the NFCC,” the auditors reported.
At the insistence of COA auditors, the DPWH management assured that all the Bids and Awards Committees (BACs), BAC Secretariats, and Technical Working Groups (TWGs) of the DPWH CO, regional and district engineering offices (ROs and DEOs) must strengthen the validation of the (NFCC) during preliminary examination of bids and post-qualification.
