“ATTORNEY, gusto ko nang ipa-annul ang kasal ko.”

For lawyers, this is probably one of the most familiar statements heard from clients whenever their marriages have irretrievably broken down. In ordinary conversations, Filipinos tend to use the word “annulment” to refer to almost every legal proceeding that ends—or at least changes—the marital relationship.

“Annulled na sila.” “Magpapa-annul na raw.” “Magkano ba ang annulment?”

Legally, however, annulment is not a catch-all term. Not all changes in marital status is annulment. The Family Code of the Philippines recognizes significant differences among declaration of absolute nullity of marriage, annulment of marriage, and legal separation.

Remember, my dear Legal Classroom readers, they are not interchangeable. And perhaps the easiest way to understand their distinctions is to ask one simple question: Was there a valid marriage in the first place?

Nullity: Marriage Void From The Beginning

In a declaration of absolute nullity, the basic legal premise is that the marriage was void from the very beginning, or void ab initio. In short, walang bisa ang kasal mula umpisa.

In the eyes of the law, a valid marriage never legally came into existence because of the absence of the essential and formal requisites recognized by the Family Code.

Under Articles 2 and 3 of the Family Code, a valid marriage requires two essential requisites: (1) the legal capacity of the parties and (2) freely given consent. It also requires three formal requisites: (1) authority of the solemnizing officer, (2) a valid marriage license unless exempted by law, and (3) a marriage ceremony where the parties personally declare their consent before the solemnizing officer and at least two witnesses of legal age.

The absence of any essential or formal requisite generally renders the marriage void from the beginning, subject to exceptions expressly provided by law.

Article 35, for example, declares certain marriages void from the beginning. These include marriages where a party was below 18 years old; certain marriages solemnized without legal authority or without the required marriage license; bigamous or polygamous marriages not falling within the exception provided by law; and marriages involving mistake as to the identity of the other contracting party. Meanwhile, Articles 37 and 38 likewise declare incestuous marriages and certain marriages contrary to public policy void from the beginning.

Then there is perhaps the most familiar ground: psychological incapacity under Article 36.

Psychological incapacity does not simply mean that the spouses are incompatible, constantly fighting, immature, or that one spouse later became irresponsible.

The law requires psychological incapacity to relate to the inability of a spouse, existing at the time of the celebration of the marriage, to comply with the essential marital obligations of marriage.

Thus, when a court declares a marriage void, it is not technically “annulling” a valid marriage. It is judicially declaring that the marriage was legally void from its inception.

Annulment: Marriage Valid—Until Annulled

Annulment of marriage is different. Here, the marriage is considered valid and binding until a court annuls it.

Article 45 of the Family Code provides specific grounds. Among them are lack of required parental consent when one party was 18 but below 21 at the time of marriage; unsoundness of mind; consent obtained through fraud; consent obtained through force, intimidation, or undue influence; incurable physical incapacity to consummate the marriage; and a serious and apparently incurable sexually transmissible disease existing at the time of marriage.

Notice the difference.

In nullity, the marriage suffers from an absence or defect so fundamental that the law regards it as void from the start. In annulment, a marriage legally exists, but a defect recognized by law makes it voidable.

Think of it this way: In nullity, there was no valid marriage from the beginning. In annulment, there was a valid marriage, but the law allows it to be annulled because of specific circumstances existing when it was celebrated.

There is another practical difference. An action or defense for declaration of absolute nullity generally does not prescribe. Actions for annulment, on the other hand, are subject to the specific periods provided under Article 47 of the Family Code.

Legal Separation: Still Married, But May Live Separately

And of course, we do have legal separation. This is perhaps the most misunderstood of the three.

Remember: Legal separation does not dissolve the marriage.

Article 63 of the Family Code makes this unmistakably clear: spouses who are legally separated may live separately from each other, but the marriage bond is not severed.

Therefore, neither spouse becomes legally single. Neither may simply marry another person. Hindi ka puwedeng magpakasal.

Fundamentally, this is what separates legal separation from absolute nullity and annulment.

Article 55 provides the grounds for legal separation. These include repeated physical violence or grossly abusive conduct; certain forms of coercion involving religious or political affiliation; attempts to corrupt or induce a spouse or child into prostitution; imprisonment for more than six years; drug addiction or habitual alcoholism; contracting a subsequent bigamous marriage; sexual infidelity or perversion; attempt against the life of the petitioner; and abandonment without justifiable cause for more than one year.

Thus, legal separation recognizes that although the marriage itself remains valid, circumstances may have become so serious that the spouses should no longer be legally required to live together.

‘Naghiwalay na Kami’ Isn’t Legal Separation

This is another common misconception. A husband and wife may have lived apart for five, ten, or even twenty years. That does not automatically make them legally separated.

Physical separation is different from legal separation. Legal separation requires a judicial proceeding and a decree from the court.

So when someone says, “Matagal na kaming separated,” that does not necessarily mean the person is legally separated in the technical or legal sense. It is actually called “separation in fact,” a situation where a husband and wife live separately and no longer share a household without any court decree, annulment, or official legal separation.

More importantly, mere separation in fact does not give either spouse the freedom to remarry.

Can the spouses remarry?

This is perhaps the simplest way for ordinary readers to distinguish the three.

After a final judgment declaring a marriage void or annulling a voidable marriage, the former spouses may generally remarry, subject to compliance with the requirements of the Family Code, including the required recording of the judgment and matters concerning the liquidation and partition of properties.

After legal separation, however, they cannot remarry each other to other persons because they remain husband and wife. The marriage continues to exist.

What happens to the children and property?

Ending or modifying the marital relationship does not erase parental responsibility.

In proceedings for nullity or annulment, the court may determine issues involving custody, support, liquidation and distribution of property, and other consequences of the judgment.

Legal separation likewise has important property consequences. The absolute community or conjugal partnership is dissolved and liquidated, and the offending spouse may lose his or her share in the net profits. The law also provides consequences involving custody and inheritance.

But whatever happens between husband and wife, the law continues to protect the rights and welfare of their children. A failed marriage does not terminate parenthood.

Nullity Is Not Divorce

One final difference deserves emphasis. A declaration of nullity is not simply Philippine divorce under another name. Neither is annulment.

Divorce generally terminates a marriage that was validly entered into based on grounds recognized by the governing divorce law.

Nullity, by contrast, proceeds from the legal conclusion that the marriage was void from the beginning. Annulment involves a voidable marriage affected by one of the specific defects provided by law. Legal separation leaves the marriage bond intact.

These differences may sound technical, but they have enormous practical consequences.

Whether a person may remarry, how properties are liquidated, what happens to inheritance rights, and what legal remedies are available depend on which proceeding actually applies.

Simply saying “Magpa-annul ka na” may be easier said than legally done.

The first question is not whether a marriage has become unhappy. But what does the law say about the marriage itself?

Was it void from the beginning? Was it valid but voidable? Or does the marriage remain valid despite circumstances that justify the spouses living separately?

Three different questions. Three different legal remedies.

And three very different consequences.

Class dismissed!