MY favorite columnist, Randy David, wrote about the huge dilemma of the poor in dealing with banks and general financial institutions (including insurance and money changers) regarding the two valid ID policy imposed by the (you guessed right), the Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas – which despite its gargantuan salaries and perks make life most difficult and miserable for the hoi poloi which I suspect it treats like criminals through its discriminatory policies.

Ordinary Pinoys can’t withdraw or deposit their hard-earned money with the banks without being required to present two valid government IDs– SSS, GSIS, voter’s ID, postal ID, barangay ID PhilHealth ID, driver’s license and, of late, the national ID (which is supposed to present the complete profile of a person) but which, again, must be accompanied by another valid government ID. 

One in 20 poor Pinoys, or those in the margins, hardly possess one and therefore they are excluded from the banking and financial system. A farmer or fisherman would be lucky to have two IDs because most of the time they borrow money from loan sharks and the friendly Bumbay who visits them religiously.

If a relative working abroad sends cash to them– either in local or foreign denomination– they still must present two valid IDs to the money changers, remittance centers and the banks. Even if they plead that they have one ID, still their money (sent to them rightfully for an emergency) would not be given to them. The financial system has lost its heart and soul because of the two- valid IDs policy.

Honestly, in my dealings with the banks, when they ask me for two valid IDs, I observe what exactly they do when they look at the IDs, they don’t even bother to check the address on the IDs,nor the signature, so why require looking at it in the first place. 

Prof. Randy David aptly described this nuisance requirement as being worse for the poor “as if they did not exist. In today’s world, this means being barred from the most basic services for lack of an acceptable identity document” right in your native land. In short it is being undocumented.”

David said: “This may feel like a sick joke played on the powerless, but it can happen to many of us. It is precisely the theme of the film “2 Valid IDs,” which was shown at the Cinemalaya film festival in August. I caught it last week in its brief commercial run, and came away feeling I had just watched one of the truest depictions of what it means to be poor in a modern society.”

Then he mentioned the film he watched at Cinemalaya which revolves around around Sylvia (sensitively played by Marietta Subong, aka “Pokwang”), a farmer who has brought her ailing husband Ramon (Joey Marquez) to Manila for treatment of his COPD (chronic obstructive pulmonary disease). They land in a crowded ward of a poorly equipped government hospital. There they find a support system among other patients’ families, and staff who make up for the hospital’s inadequacies with simple acts of kindness.

Ramon needs surgery, but the wait is long and uncertain. He could be prioritized, they are told, if he were moved to a semiprivate room. Sylvia persuades a relative of Ramon’s working in New Zealand to send money in exchange for a piece of land. The amount (over a hundred thousand pesos) is promptly wired. That is where the trouble begins.

At the remittance center, Sylvia is told the PhilHealth card is no longer accepted as a primary identification card. She needs to present two from an approved list: passport, driver’s license, national ID, Unified Multi-Purpose ID, National Bureau of Investigation clearance, voter’s ID, postal ID, senior citizen’s ID, and so on. She has none of these.

Mercy, a relative who has given them shelter during their stay in the city, knows the way. Through her connection with a barangay official, she gets Sylvia a barangay clearance. A fixer supplies the voter’s registration forms. Sylvia has her biometrics taken at city hall and, days later, gets her voter’s certification. She uses it to apply for a postal ID: more biometrics, another week’s wait. Ramon’s condition worsens. Sylvia returns to the remittance center to plead that one ID should suffice. “Do I look like a cheat?” she quietly protests. She is politely told to come back with two valid IDs.

When the postal ID is finally released, she rushes back to get her money. The queue is long. A text message arrives. She tries to cut in, begging for understanding, and loses her composure when people at the back tell her to fall in line. I will not reveal how the film ends, except to say that Sylvia bears all this without self-pity.

Without an ID, she cannot claim money that is already hers. Without the money, her husband cannot be moved up for surgery. No one in this chain is cruel. The girl at the remittance center follows the rule, and the rule is there, she explains, to prevent fraud. The refusal is firm and real; yet it has no author.

In the hospital ward, people look after one another on the basis of personal trust. But that trust counts for nothing at the remittance counter, which recognizes only documents. The irony is that Sylvia can enter this impersonal world only through the old personal channels: a relative’s barangay connection and a fixer. And to collect a family remittance, she must first become a registered voter.

We are witnessing a new way of doing things. It is one that no longer runs on personal trust but on verified identity. Years ago, many resisted a national ID system for demanding too much personal information. 

Today, people surrender far more to e-wallet providers and remittance firms, because these have become necessities. Meanwhile, the process of getting a national ID remains slow. The system is unable to serve those who need it most, many of whose paper trail fails at the very first documentary requirement, the birth certificate.

The promise of modernity has always been that the circumstances of one’s birth shall no longer determine admission to schools, the economy, citizenship, or the courts. What has been overlooked is that access to all these depends, in the first instance, on being recognized as a person.

Before anyone asks whether you qualify, the question is whether you exist–i.e., on paper. That question now comes before all others. No valid ID, no entry, David concluded.

But let me take you to another dimension– the super rich and influential and the regular patrons of banks and financial systems never need to present two valid IDs– all that’s required is face value. See how unjust, unfair and lopsided our systems are!

Many times, the ordinary bank clients have to wait for their numbers to be flashed on the screens. But the rich they enter, are attended to with dispatch and voila they leave a few minutes later, no waiting necessary.

Ours is a society that caters to the rich, popular, powerful and influential. But if you are neither of these adjectives, just wait for your turn to be called. Yet, it is us the less powerful, the middle class that pay more taxes than the rich and it is us that do not hide stolen wealth abroad.